Haunted by the memory of Walter Holderlin, a soldier he killed during World War I, French musician Paul Renard (Phillips Holmes) confesses to a priest (Frank Sheridan), who grants him absolution. Using the address on a letter he found on the dead man's body, Paul then travels to Germany to find his family.
As anti-French sentiment continues to permeate Germany, Dr. Holderlin (Lionel Barrymore) initially refuses to welcome Paul into his home, but changes his mind when his son's fiancée Elsa identifies him as the man who has been leaving flowers on Walter's grave. Rather than reveal the real connection between them, Paul tells the Holderlin family he was a friend of their son, who attended the same musical conservatory he did.
Although the hostile townspeople and local gossips disapprove, the Holderlins befriend Paul, who finds himself falling in love with Elsa (Nancy Carroll). When she shows Paul her former fiancé's bedroom, he becomes distraught and tells her the truth. She convinces him not to confess to Walter's parents, who have embraced him as their second son, and Paul agrees to forego easing his conscience and stays with his adopted family. Dr. Holderlin presents Walter's violin to Paul, who plays it while Elsa accompanies him on the piano.
The film's original title, The Man I Killed, was changed to The Fifth Commandment to avoid giving "wrong impressions in the minds of the public about the character of the story." It ultimately was released as Broken Lullaby.
男主勇敢，温暖。女主有点变扭。但是喜欢happy ending！
麦克是比较帅的，也有一定经济实力，性格还非常好，但他是玛丽苏文学中完美的人吗？我觉得不是，丫脑子有点问题，完全无法理解他爱上一个妓女。他不在乎安吉尔以前的千人骑万人跨就罢了，但安吉尔中间弃家后跟麦克妹夫发生关系，又去酒馆做妓女，这就实在让我无法接受了，这是习惯把腿张开的生活了啊......这就是我对这片子前半段的感受。不过后1/3却让我有了不同的感受，安吉尔（莎拉）的改变和坚强又让我有了不同的感受，最后俩人的爱情差点让我掉泪。整体来说，本片还是可以的，也有一些不错的地方，片尾的歌曲很好听，是不是阿黛尔的，有加分！我给4星7.2分！
男主勇敢，温暖。女主有点变扭。但是喜欢happy ending！
Nothing is impossible
剑，最要远离的真的是女人
大体还是延续了上一部的风格和主要演员，2021年的故事更多，这些角色依然还是那么愚蠢和可笑，我最喜欢英国的那个傻妞。为什么片中没有提及美国的反亚裔问题？刘玉玲白出演了
没有想到顺顺居然喜欢看，说看到美国这么烂，她很高兴。#20220115
女主对被摧毁过的爱和信任的重新接受。除了开头的突然爱上很奇怪。
love and forgiveness can heal everything.
女主的每一次出走，都是不断成长，到最后成为一位厨师，无疑是最成功的。
玛丽苏烂片，两星给男女主颜值，一星给滤镜，男主超级大舔狗
虽然风景美、人也美，但我是真看不下去…虽然女主从小就被男人伤害但遇到男主后还总是跑…男主去找她 她就跟回来…男主简直就是天使转世吧 拯救女主
年终总结，新的一年，真的是没有吸取到一点点教训。。。
以前都是看科幻警匪片，第一次看这种美国电影，老实说按咱们这边的爱情观来看这电影，属实有点大开眼界，叹服美国性观念的确开放！劝妓从良娶回家又逃出去卖，路上还给妹夫口，男主却依然如初把女主带回来，几人生活在一个农场不尴尬么...最离谱就是流产导致没有生育能力的女主，结尾愣是又给怀上了。但如果站在全片主线讲述女主复仇，男女主爱情为辅的角度来看，就说的通为何三番两次为何逃跑了：复仇一：幼时女主和母亲被父亲抛弃失去经济来源，母亲靠出卖肉体为生，母亲病死后，女主被人卖到妓院豢养接客，长大后遇见生父，与生父发生关系，生父饮弹自尽。复仇2：女主有2个妓院好友被火烧死，于是就下定决心找侯爵报仇，带着这种复仇为主线，爱情为辅的角度来看这片，就说得通三番二次逃跑了...可惜并不是这样拍摄的...
好吧，我承认现实中肯定没有这样的爱情。但是我还是好感动呀。都看哭了。这是一种救赎的爱吧。一种补偿。我很不理解的是，为什么后面他们有孩子了？
一见钟情的男人，不在乎女人的过往，正因为男人的爱，也拯救了女人，让女人在生活中再次遇到困难时，做出了正确的选择，两人最终收获爱情，喜欢电影的剧情，配乐，真的很棒！
摄影很美，画面很美。一开始看得很窝火，感觉不自重的女主一直想外逃，男主就是上帝吧，一直无条件爱她，见了第一眼就已经爱得无法自拔，这世上有这等好男子？
当代美国混乱大事记，罗里吧嗦废话太多了，毁灭吧，赶紧的。
有2020去死在前，倒没那么多惊喜了，毕竟已经重新认识人类这一物种两年了，毫不吃惊……
I hear you whisper underneath your breath
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
